Round 2 - Division 3 Voting

WTB 2013 Round 2 voting

This is the voting thread for Round 2 - Division 3. Please vote for entries in this division only.

You do not have to vote for Teams that are the same country, an average score will be given to them to even things out.
Please vote fairly as to who you think have created the best chop in terms of realism, quality and execution.

You have until SUNDAY 14th July 2013 to vote. (Click to see time)
From this point on, any Late entries will be penaltized 20%

Voting Format:
10 Pts- Team AA
9 Pts- Team BB
8 pts- Team CC

For reference, this is the base image:

8985810231_c62e21ec8c_b.jpg


-Team France 2
p1gr.jpg
Wip: http://img442.imageshack.us/img442/2918/srbs.jpg
Donor: http://img37.imageshack.us/img37/8541/f65g.jpg

-Team Serbia
jzgb.jpg
Wips: http://imageshack.us/a/img577/213/x04p.jpg
Donor: http://imageshack.us/a/img841/3954/0uyq.jpg

-Team Brazil 2
z8jh.jpg
Wip: http://img20.imageshack.us/img20/2489/h520.jpg
Donor: http://img706.imageshack.us/img706/9051/hiwk.jpg

-Team Spain 1
qmg4.jpg
Wip: http://img1.imagebanana.com/img/66v999hk/WipsDonors.jpg

No Submission :(
-Team Turkey 10
-Team Brazil 4
-Team Turkey 8
-Team Egypt
Post edited July 08, 2013 at 06:14:47 AM by J_HUI
ffkZ5K.jpg
Come join us on Facebook and Tumblr
This is by far the hardest division to vote in, with very little seperating the chops. I had to think long and hard before award these points:

10pts - Team Serbia - one of my favourite entries from all of the divisions actually! The design is bold and powerful, and fits beautifully with the original lines, to create somethign that is really very beautiful to look at. It's been superbly widened too, very few have managed to pull of a wide kit with this base, so for this I salute you. The more I look at the chop, the more I like it also, especially those front lights! Overall brilliant piece with lots of cool little details. Only thing that bothers me is the front tyre seems far to thin. Everything else - love it! :D

9pts - Team Brazil 2 - To really appreciate this chop, you have to look at the high resolution. There's some lovely brushwork demonstrated here, with great overall lighting feel. All mods seem well thought out, and are executed to a high standard with some creative extras. The estate conversion is particularly good, and there are some nice details thrown in too. Main issue for me is that the intercooler and front rim seem to be a little off - everything else is great :D

8pts - Team France 2 - Initially I expected to be voting this first, but the quality of the other entries was just so high. Believe me though, it's only just off the top spot. For me there are a few issues which let it down, which is why I have not voted this piece quite so highly. Firstly, the rear wheel appears to be slightly flat. Not only that but both wheels and the carbon splitter and sideskirt have lighting that really doesn't seem to fit with the rest of the chop. The overall lighting of the paint is one of the best bits on this piece, however there feels to be inconsitency in the realism and quality, with the lighitng not quite flowing from body panel to body panel - it alos lacks any sort of noise and feels far too smooth. I'm personally not a fan of some of the design choices in regards to the bonnet, it's lost some of the original shape without good reason I feel. Only other thing is that the roll cage looks pasted over teh windscreen, like the reflections are below it. Overall good chop though, I expect you will do well :D

7pts - Team Spain 1 - I vcannot believe that I'm having to vote this so low down O.o The amount of detail and quality of all the mods is simply stunning. Not only that but it's put together extremely creatively. However for me, looking at the overall piece as a chop, it doesn't quite work. I'm not quite sure why, but I would imagine it's to do with a few perspective and lighting issues. There's no way of putting this really, other than, the backdrop does not fit. The perspective of the car is a lot more extreme and as a result it just doesn't seem to work. The flames seem very out of place too, with no blur at all and very little lighting given off from them, it just feels like it's been pasted as an after thought. The main reason I feel I can't vote this quite so high up is because the design doesn't quite work for me. The whole car feels extremely tall, taller than the base almost, with a very boxy kit that doesn't seem to flow into the base's lines - a few paradoxical shapes here and there too. Despite this SOME OF THE BEST BRUSHING I'VE SEEN IN A LONG TIME. You will go far in this competition if you continue in the same way! :D
125q72h.jpg
>>Latest Chop<<
| >>Like my Facebook Page<< | >>Basic Brushing Tutorial<<
Okay,so:
10 Team Serbia -Amazing work! nice color combo :)
9 Team France 2 -Nice chop,lovely brush,but the design of hood looks artificially
8 Team Brazil 2 -I don't like the look of front emblem and the rear windows looks like bmw 3er..but the chop looks good :)
7 Team spain 1 -Nice brush,nice details..but i really don't like the design .. :)
failfinal.png
My facebook webpage
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Richardsvec-designs/499018533494951?ref=ts&amp;fref=ts
The second best division for voting :mrteeth:

I just cannot choose which one .. but I'll try.

10 Points - Team Serbia - love everything. Nice combo of colors, nice wheels, nice smoke...
9 Points - Team Brazil 2 - The best color of them all! AND it's a WAGON. Well :-d
8 Points - Team France 2 - Nice and simple.
7 Points - Team Spain 1 - It is real, but also not so real. The only bad things I can say is about that weird blur.. everything else is just nice.

It looks easy, but I wish I could add 2 of them for 10 points, and the other two for 9 points .. they are just awesome works, congrats.
WTB 2011 - Team Bulgaria 1
10-Team Spain 1
9-Team Brazil 2
8-Team Serbia
7-Team France 2
10pt-Team Frane2
9pt-Team Brazil 2
8pt- Team Serbia
10 pts -Team Brazil 2
9 pts -Team Serbia
8 pts -Team Spain 1
391722bannierefrteam2.jpg
10 Points - Team Serbia
9 Points - Team Spain 1
8 Points - Team France 2
7 Points - Team Brazil 2
10 pts : Team Serbia
9 pts : Team Brazil 2
8 pts : Team France 2
7 pts : Team Spain 1
10pts - Team Serbia
9pts - Team Brazil
8pts - Team France
7pts - Team Spain
th1.png
Back to top

Please login to post