MOVED: VOTING: [ASC 2012] Semi Final

1 person favorited this.
VOTING: [ASC 2012] Semi Final

ascinterlaced.png

IF YOU COMPETED IN THIS ROUND, DO NOT VOTE.


For reference, here was the task:
Quote:
YOUR TASK

Rivals Theme: Ferrari vs Lamborghini

Now that we've tested your designing capabilities, we want to see the artistry and creativity hidden behind those more technical talents ...

In this Round we want you to compose a piece of art that represents the long and epic rivalry between two of the world's most distinctive car manufacturers: Ferrari and Lamborghini. You are free to choose whatever base images you like - be it the latest models from each manufacturer, or perhaps some that go back to the roots of the rivalry - creativity is all we ask!

With all this freedom comes a two crucial theme requirements:
- You may produce more than one final image as your entry
- However, one of your images must feature at least one vehicle from both brands in the same image

Have fun, try your best, and remember; be creative!



hugosilva

hugoentry800.jpg

WIPs

_________________________________________________________________________

rookiejeno

asc3800.jpg

WIPs

_________________________________________________________________________

Zykotec

LateVicesmall.jpg

AlpineVicesmall.jpg

WIPs

_________________________________________________________________________

-xanforce-

ascr3fefvslambo02byxanf.jpg

ascr3fefvslambo02byxanf.jpg

WIPs

_________________________________________________________________________

hege

wip6800.jpg

WIPs

_________________________________________________________________________

VOTING RULES

  • Do your best to vote unbiased towards others based on their nationality, or simply because you like/dislike them.
  • Do not vote in a division you have competed in.

  • Vote for the TOP 4 chops in the following format:

    4 points = M4D Creations (Given to the best entry)
    3 points = B0$$ Designs (Given to the second best entry)
    2 point = Puszka1232122312 (Given to the third best entry)
    2 point = Cool_designer (Given to the fourth best entry)

  • We ask you to write a farily extensive critique on the work of those that you are voting for. This should include an explanation of why you are placing the chop in that position.

The TOP 4 voted chops in progress to the Final.
Post edited December 30, 2012 at 06:06:23 PM by Klaus
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
EDIT: Came back for another look and the task description caught my eye. I had to modify my votes accordingly.

4p to xan: Hands down winner for creativity while also being of very high standard technically. (Old comment: First off I'd like to say I would have wanted to give 197 points to xan's concept work but I'm not getting the intense rivalry action feeling from it. It looks more like a showcase, like a scene just before it's really on. Maybe if the wheels were spinning it would have fooled me enough. :D The cars look amazing and even without reading the texts in the image it totally said modern Miura to me. Took a bit longer to figure out the other one's a modern Dino but now that I look at it again I keep thinking "Well of course". Definitely the most interesting entry on this round, I just find it not fulfilling the rivalry criteria well enough to pass the other entries. The Miura especially looks something I would love to model in 3d and import into a game engine.)

3p to hugosilva: A perfect action scene with great execution. Almost looks like it could be a screen shot from Hot Pursuit or something. Great composition, angle and lighting. Only thing I noticed missing are the headlights' reflections on the ground.

2p to rookiejeno: Another good action shot depicting rivalry. The blue tint is a nice effect and I like how the red Frari pops out of the picture. The paint on the Lambo looks technically awesome but maybe it kind of gets lost into the blue background. On the other hand it is quite big in the image and easy to spot because of that so maybe it doesn't need a coloured paint. I'm not a fan of the white wheels, both style-wise but also because they seem to be a little low-quality compared to the rest of the image.

1p to hege: Amazing image quality on this one, it looks as if I could touch the Lambo! Lambo is definitely the best part in this one. The paint on the Ferrari looks a bit flat because it has no reflections on it while the other car has. Some darker hues on both the cars would have also been in order to make it look more like a night scene.Also, they're driving at night and blasting their headlights head-on towards the viewer so you'd expect a lot stronger effects from the headlights. I'm sure it would have given it a lot stronger mood for the image. The police car kind of gets lost in the motion blur and because of it the bg has no depth. Also on the right edge of the image there's a strange directions difference in the motion blur effect which also eats away the wow factor. And again, a tighter cropping and maybe a more severe angle for the camera would have definitely made this a more striking image. 4:3 image ratio rarely packs a punch.

Zykotec: It definitely has action and the rivalry going to some extent. To me, Sonny kind of distracts from the car rivalry there for a bit. Lots of small errors, flat wheels and bad quality donors (should have left the second version out as the blue paint on the Countach brings out the bad image quality). The mountains actually look more in focus (and in better image quality) than the cars on the foreground. Comparing it aesthetically to the other entries this one falls far behind. There's no dynamic in the composition since both of the cars are in a simple quarter view and the leveled-out view further diminishes the effect of a high-speed pursuit.
Post edited December 19, 2012 at 10:34:56 PM by ollite20
1 person liked this.
4 Points = -xanforce-

In contrast to Olli's opinion, I actually like the route that -xanforce- has gone down with his entry. In my opinion it better represents the "long and epic rivalry" of Ferrari and Lamborghini than any of the other entries, as he's actually looked back at two of the iconic cars from each manufacturer that rooted the rivalry, and pitted them against one another for another time - with a redesign twist. As usual, the design of each on is impeccable (you really should be doing this for a living if you aren't already!) and the finishing is top notch. One thing I'd love to see you do is use your designing and artistic skills to produce a photo-realistic piece, rather than a render/sketch final entry. Great stuff again though!

3 Points = hugosilva

Very difficult to fault, and although the NFS theme is a little timeworn this is probably one of the best incarnations I've seen of it. Top notch stuff :-d

2 Points = rookiejeno

Loving the effects, although as an image it feels a little too chaotic and messy. Although that may have been the aim, I do like some order and a defined subject in a piece like this, otherwise it loses my attention quite quickly.

1 Point = Zykotec

Very difficult to choose between yours and hege's, but you edge him out based on the amazing realism in this chop. However, the bra and the dude shooting is pretty tacky and both look like last minute additions.
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
4 Points = hugosilva
- Nicely done! Great atmosphere!

3 Points = rookiejeno
- I liked this when I saw this. Nicely done!

2 Points = -xanforce-
- A great concept! I would have liked more if it had been a "real chop."

1 Point = Zykotec
- Nice mountain chase scene. Latevice atmosphere is fantastic!
great!
4 Points = -xanforce-
So cool that you redesigned 2 new models from the past, respect for the skill and design work put in!

3 Points =hugosilva
Damn that's a great looking chop, Lambo looks sooo sexy! Awesome level of realism on it too, overall awesome picture.

2 Points = Rookiejeno
Cars look great, the blue of the background annoys me a lot though.

1 Point = Zykotec
Awesome periodically correct modification of the cars! Cool theme and scenery too.
4 points = hugosilva - My! What a stunning piece of art! Staying true to the rival's theme but in a totally different way, and very original for this round! Cop vs Racer :D I love every bit, especially that gorgeous sunset, wet atmosphere. The transformation of the ferrari is insane,, and the lambo's paint is equally sexy. My only criticism would be that the lambo doesn't quite feel to fit on the backdrop. You see too much of it's roof I think :P

3 points = -xanforce- - well, the amount of effort and creativity here is mind blowing! While it may not quite show the same sense of 'rivalry' it's certainly an incredible piece. I love how you've brought back to life old classics and given them a new twist, and the accompanying wip work just adds to the awesomeness. All that stopped me dropping this into first place was that it didn't quite have the same sense of rivalry as the other chops. Never the less, great work :D

2 points = Rookiejeno - a very nice piece with some great skill and attention to detail. The overall composition is great too, however the ferrari's positioning really lets it down for me - it doesn't quite feel like it sits on the backdrop right, and for me I'd like to see the front wheels turning into the slide rather than still pointing straight forward - I feel it would make the image a little more dynamic. The rear lights on the lambo and flame could use some work too - they feel a bit flat and fake. Everything else is cool though - a lovely piece of work :)

1 point = hege - compared to the bases there seems to have been more overall effort put in here, and for me this captures the spirit of the competition slightly more :P I really like the subtle mods on the lambo, especially the addition of the new reflections, which just add to the overall atmosphere in the new backdrop. I feel the ferrari's paint could use a little work, however overall a very nice looking piece.


@Zyko - for me, there isn't quite enough of a transformation from the bases - If I compare the quantity of work on yours and hege's I'm afraid his just edges it. There's also the slight issue that the countach and F40 aren't really rivals... they're about 20 years apart from each other XD ;) Also some slightly noobish mistakes, like flat front wheels on both cars, and lighting that really doesn't match on the extra additions. Despite that some cool ideas - it will be interesting to see which of you or hege progresses.
125q72h.jpg
>>Latest Chop<<
| >>Like my Facebook Page<< | >>Basic Brushing Tutorial<<
4 points - hugosilve
Stunning work, only let down is a few reflections like the lights of the police car and the reflection of the police car on the Lambo, should be a lot further forward.

3 points - xanforce
Awesome designs, but I want to see a realistic render.

2 points - Rookiejeno
A lot of mistakes like wheels spinning but very little motion blur on the background. BG too blue for my liking and the Ferrari is too far/small in the image.

1 point - Zykotec
Top image is far better but would have liked to see the Lambo in yellow though, as both being the same colour doesn't make them seem like rivalries. The wheels are the biggest let down of your chops.

hege - This didn't quite make it, as there isn't much rivalry between the Lambo and Ferrari IMO.
4pts - Hugosilva
3pts - xanforce
2pts - rookiejeno
1pts - Zykotec
4Pts: Hugoooo!!
I agree with ATC, this chop shows more rivalry which was the theme of the chop which is why I gave this chop an edge over Xan and the finished work just looks amazing!!
(only thing that sticks out is the lambo badge, I think it needs a bit more glare from the sun, it's too dark atm)

3Pts: -xanforce-, Didnt expect anything less from you Xan, amazing work taking 2 classic super cars and giving them a transformation making them fresh and futuristic. Amazing work as always! :)

2Pts: rookiejeno The scenery of this chop screams awesome, love the cold blue background. But I feel there was a few minor flaws. But still an outstanding chop, well done.

1Pts
Very tough choice, but I think I'll give it to Zyko for creativity. The chop lacks the high quality, but makes up with the theme and details in the chop.

Hege, Big fan of your work and this chop, but the Ferrari looks very pasted in and lacks the reflection/ highlights/ details needed on the car, the lambo by itself is amazing and just pops out from my screen! XD
ffkZ5K.jpg
Come join us on Facebook and Tumblr
4 points : hugosilva - Very, very nice! Some mistakes though, the BG is still a bit off, the rearwheel of the Lamborghini looks very skinny and a right-hand-drive NYPD-car? :P

3 points : -xanforce- - Love the designs you did. Only because the rivalry was clearer in Hugo's chop this didn't make 1st place.

2 points : Rookiejeno - Not much to say actually. I really like it, and it's all done very well, just got the feeling the refs could be so much cooler in the kind of BG even if the Aventador is matte. Not an easy task though...

1 point : Zykotec - I like the oldschool rivalry in this pic. Just still too many mistakes to end up higher in the ranking. Eg, the weird sunspot on the road, hue of the flipup lights of F40, lighting on rims Countach..
induslogodapaut.png
induslogodapautond.png
Back to top

Please login to post