MOVED: VOTING: [ASC 2012] Round 2 - Division 2

VOTING: [ASC 2012] Round 2 - Division 2

ascinterlaced.png

IF YOU COMPETED IN THIS DIVISION, DO NOT VOTE IN THIS DIVISION.


For reference, here was the task:
Quote:
YOUR TASK

Honda S3000

With the Subaru BRZ / Toyota '86 being such a successful venture for those two Automotive companies, it's not a stretch to suggest that Honda may feed off their success with a new two door coupe/convertible derived from the successful S2000.

What we want to you do this round is bring back this legend of a car, with a Honda S3000 concept. For freedom there is no set base, however we do suggest you use a S2000 as a guide for perspectives and/or body lines.

The best entries will be ones that combine the elements of the previous generation S2000, with contemporary design. Your design should also seem to "fit in" with the current Honda vehicle line.

We do not want to see a simple chop of an S2000 - judges will be rewarding creative and original designs!



GTstudio

s3k1.jpg
WIPs

image reference

_________________________________________________________________________


hugosilva

finalhondas3000jpglowre.jpg
WIPs
Base

_________________________________________________________________________

TK Tuning
hondas3000ready800x.jpg
WIPs

_________________________________________________________________________


elmo28

s3000conceptbig.jpg
WIP
WIP
WIP
WIP
WIP

Base

_________________________________________________________________________


Matt_K

finalm.jpg
WIP


_________________________________________________________________________

-xanforce-

ascr2hondas22byxanforce.jpg
Sketches
WIPs
Base

_________________________________________________________________________



VOTING RULES

  • Do your best to vote unbiased towards others based on their nationality, or simply because you like/dislike them.
  • Do not vote in a division you have competed in.

  • Vote for the TOP 4 chops in the following format:

    4 points = M4D Creations (Given to the best entry)
    3 points = B0$$ Designs (Given to the second best entry)
    2 point = Puszka1232122312 (Given to the third best entry)
    2 point = Cool_designer (Given to the fourth best entry)

  • We ask you to write a farily extensive critique on the work of those that you are voting for. This should include an explanation of why you are placing the chop in that position.

The TOP 4 voted chops in this division progress to the Semi Final.
Post edited November 07, 2012 at 08:10:28 AM by Klaus
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
4 points -xanforce- Just incredble mindblowing, no words really .

3 points Hugo Amazing artwork, insane render so well done

2 pponts GS Studio Love the look of the rear and top, so clean .

1 points Points TK Tuning Love the wheels and color of the car
I've amended what you've pointed out -xanforce- (blame Hui not me as he wrote this thread, and I simply C&Pd it across - but in all seriousness Hui <3).

Also deleted your comment in case other competitors see it as unfair to have your chop get extra attention. ;)

Here's my votes:

4 Points = -xanforce-

Simply amazing! Great design, and very good rendering. The "sketchy" look is very appropriate for a theme like this.

3 Points = hugosilva

Design wise it doesn't quite match up to -xanforce- and considering this was a design theme, that's why I went with -xanforce-'s entry for 4 points. It's hard to fault it technically though - very good work!

2 Points = TK Tuning

I actually really like the design, although I don't like the fact that you've modded it. A stock version would have been more appropriate, and perhaps have edged ahead of Hugo's chop as I think your design is more realistic approach to what Honda could do.

1 Point = GTstudio

Pretty cool, but doesn't really feel enough like an S2000 or a Honda for that matter. The Toyota body lines are quite obvious still, and it also has a 370Z shape to it. Maybe if you'd made it a convertible it'd look a bit better, but I'm not sure. Still, good execution and a nice entry overall.
Post edited November 01, 2012 at 11:58:09 AM by Klaus
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
4 points -xanforce-
3 points GTstudio
2 pponts Hugosilva
1 points TK Tuning
4 Points = -xanforce-
Simply awesome! I see a clear lines of the s2000, although it is entirely changed.
Great work!

3 Points = TK Tuning
Nice shapes! Color combination is awesome!
I find a few small mistake, but the design is better than Hugo.

2 Points = hugosilva
Well done, and great atmosphere. This has been done very well! Design is a bit too "box" for me.

1 Point = GTstudio
Great job.
4 points = TK Tuning - it may be modified, but damn that's extremely sexy! It looks very much like a honda, and is in keeping with their current design trends. If i'm totally honest, if honda were to release a replacement for the s2000, this is how I'd want it to look! Absolutely love it :D

3 points = -xanforce- - presented extremely professionally, I really love that sketchy style. As for the actual design it's also of a top quality. Some very clear infulences that look great, but perhaps a tiny bit too much like the old s2000. Having said that it still looks great, Just the roof area and rear that let it down on the design front for me.

2 points = GT Studio - again this feels very much like a honda! :D I really like the way the various body lines flow together, and overall it produces a very nice looking car. I can't help but feel that the bonnet feel a bit dated, and it's not a convertible D: That's a real shame for me. Only other thing is that it feels a little toony, but I guess that was part of the feel you were going for, so overall a nice chop.

1 point = Hugosilva - it pains me to put this entry so low, the exectuion is top notch! That lighting, that paint! So realistic! However the design is what this task is rated on, and (as you already know I think) I'm not the biggest fan, for me it just feels that bit too square, the front vents, the roof... Again it doesn't appear to be a soft top, and I feel that the overall proportions are more in keeping with that of a suzuki cappuccino now that I see it in its finished form. Never the less, a good effort :) Well done
125q72h.jpg
>>Latest Chop<<
| >>Like my Facebook Page<< | >>Basic Brushing Tutorial<<
4 points -xanforce- Design doesnt scream Honda to me but as an overall design direction it's fairly good. Honda has to go some direction, might as well be this one.
3 points - Hugosilva - This would've won quite easily if the design didnt look as outdated. To me instead of an S3000 it became an S2000.001. Execution is brilliant though.

Now we get into less thought through territory in my opinion. CRZ influence is clear.

2 points - TK Tuning - The tuning aspects let this down big time. I also recognize the styling elements from other cars very easily.
1 point - GTstudio - Despite the references looks a little too much like a CRZ.

The ones that didnt make the cut dont have anything to do with Honda in my opinion.
Post edited November 04, 2012 at 03:42:20 AM by Bart
Artist formerly known as "Dev"
Oh my god yes! great division/ entries in the round, very hard to judge as everyone have a very different style.

4pts: -xanforce-, Very professional looking presentation, cant really say much apart from it looking like a future S2000 on steroids. XD

3pts: Hugosilva, There's something different about this chop to his usual style, I love it, the atmosphere and chop. But something about the proportion/ size of the car reminds me of a Honda Beat

2pts: elmo28, I want to reward elmo as he was one of the only that seemed to have made a total new car from scratch based on a S2000, the skirt. door area could use a bit more reflection, but I quite like the design.

1pts: GT Studio, it does look a tad crz ish, but excellent execution and rendering skills as usual. (I only gave him 1 point as he is definitely going to the next round, so Im trying to be the wild card vote in the division.)

TK's entry was supurb, but it looks like a very heavily modded crz targa instead of a S3000 concept.
ffkZ5K.jpg
Come join us on Facebook and Tumblr
4 points -xanforce- Awesome artwork, even if rearend may not look too much like a Honda

3 points Hugo Neat, looks like a Honda, I know roof isn't too tall, but looks like it is anyway :P

2 points GTStudio Love the look, but very much of donor is visible. Still a nice design

1 points Points TK Tuning Nice colors, looks too much modified, not much like a concept.
Some men just want to watch the world doing burnouts... :P
bannerda.jpg bannerfb.jpg
Back to top

Please login to post