MOVED: VOTING: [BPC 2012] Round 2 - Division 1

VOTING: [BPC 2012] Round 2 - Division 1

IF YOU COMPETED IN THIS DIVISION, DO NOT VOTE IN THIS DIVISION.


For reference, here was the task:
Quote:
YOUR TASK

Nissan S15

The Nissan S15 is a truly iconic vehicle.

With the ASC competitors tackling a redesign of the S15, we want you guys to tackle a slightly less demanding task of simply "chopping" the S15.

Without further ado, here is your base image:

diggers020.jpg



DaniG Design

silvias15final1600px.jpg
WIP

_________________________________________________________________________

NS Design

silvia%20resized.jpg
WIP

_________________________________________________________________________

andre16vag
finishedrf.jpg

WIP


_________________________________________________________________________

rap
nissansilviavalmis.jpg

WIP


_________________________________________________________________________

iCreate
bpcround2s15icreatelowr.jpg

WIP
WIP2
WIP3
WIP4


_________________________________________________________________________

chibas
nissansilvias151024.jpg

_________________________________________________________________________



VOTING RULES

  • Do your best to vote unbiased towards others based on their nationality, or simply because you like/dislike them.
  • Do not vote in a division you have competed in.

  • Vote for the TOP 4 chops in the following format:

    4 points = M4D Creations (Given to the best entry)
    3 points = B0$$ Designs (Given to the second best entry)
    2 point = Puszka1232122312 (Given to the third best entry)
    2 point = Cool_designer (Given to the fourth best entry)

  • We ask you to write a farily extensive critique on the work of those that you are voting for. This should include an explanation of why you are placing the chop in that position.

The TOP 4 voted chops in this division progress to the Semi Final.
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
4 points chibas
***
Great kit and beautifull color
just somes problems of integration @ the BG... well done. :-d

3 points DaniG Design
***-
Great athmosphere :-d ,maybe too "flat" for a perfect integration...
try a little more modulations of color for the next time...

2 points iCreate
***-
Good intentions, a lovely front face, but somes big problems like wheels axes, shadows integrations, etc...

1 points NS Design
**++
idea and athmo are great...
but it's a pitty, why all this "fuzzy effect" on the car ???
Post edited October 31, 2012 at 10:20:01 PM by -xanforce-
4 points = DaniG Design

+ Nice! It is great that you have put a different front bumper than usual! The atmosphere is great.
- Background seems to be a little off. Brushing is successful, but a bit weird, a lot of shine, but you can find a lot of "semi-matte" areas. Roof is toony.

Nice work!

3 points = chibas
+ Stylish kit! I like the color!
- Very, very blurry! Shadows missing etc..

2 points = iCreate
+ Clean and tidy.
- Rear tires missing a big piece. Just boring.

1 point = NS Design
+ I like falken Silvia! Great atmosphere and lights.
- Flat shapes
4 points Danig Design
3 points iCreate
2 points NS Design
1 points Chibas

andre16vag, seriously, too much civic man! :"(
4pts: DaniG Design, Impressive looking chop, I'm surprised how well the altezza front bar actually fits the S15!

3pts: iCreate, Although not the best chop overall. I give him credit for keeping it simple and sticking to the base image so much and just trying to alter the base image, very like my style.

2pts: NS Design, great chop, it's good to see people actually "chopping" cars and not just using one paint/ wheel donor. C&C wise the proportion on the back end of the car looks strange/ squashed, the smoke should be darker and denser and also the lines for the bonnet/ bumpers are missing.

1pts: Chibas Im a bit skeptical as there wasn't a wip, I know ive seen those rims on a S15 before and im worried the whole chop is just a copy and paste with a colour change.


Andre16vag, way too much civic donor used. :/
Rap, Love the girls as usual, but just not enough done on the car to be mentioned.
ffkZ5K.jpg
Come join us on Facebook and Tumblr
Rather disappointing compared to the other division. There's probably only 1 chop here that would cut it in Pro, whereas the other division there were 3 or 4.

4 Points = DaniG Design - Clean & well executed
3 Points = chibas - Love the style, brush needs more work
2 Points = iCreate - Decent brushwork, ok styling
1 Point = andre16vag - Interesting styling, good execution
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
4p to andre16vag: Good to see something out of the ordinary. Eurostyle looks good. Only real crit that comes to my mind is the bonnet. Comes off as a bit too shiny and it would look more believable if it was a bit darker and not as saturated.

3p to chibas: Nice work on the paint! Body mods are a bit too basic for me to go 'wow' but out of the rest this one's the best quality.

2p to DaniG: Nice work on the paint although it comes off a bit flat. It needs brighter and darker hues to emphasize the paint. At the moment the paint looks like it doesn't fit into the image.

1p to rap: Lowrider wheels showed promise but I wish you would have gone further with the lowrider style on this. Now it's just a Japanese sports car with weird wheels.
Thread moved
Back to top

Please login to post