jackdarton wrote:
I vote HOF on this thread

But seriously... I think you've touched on something which a lot of people won't like there, but I love a good debate. I agree with what you said regarding defining art is impossible, art is what you want it to be. However, one admins definition of what belongs in HOF my differ from another admin's idea because it's opinion based. That's why we take heed when people call out HOF, because then its more or less a majority vote which gives us a big hand in deciding. If everybody thinks it should go in a showroom, then why shouldn't it. IMO if it's good enough for (enough) people to cry HOF then... it's HOF. There's no criteria to follow as far as I know, just every now and then something crops up which makes you sit back and think "wow"

well spoken Jack ;) I agree as well
with this

glac
yeah, it's bloody annoying, when I go into hall of fame, I wanna see something that'll wow me so much that i'll shit my pants...
2ut3p10.png
agree with j and jack,
in a year we will have like 50 chops in hof but its admin opinion based
it has started again
i wonder have most of the people who suggests hof ever even visited hof-gallery?
Nordic you should post any stupidly, unreasonable HOF shout's here and i'll try to deal with it :-d

*Puts on the flaming suit, and opens Google translate*


But at the same time, the chopping scene standards has gone through the roof this year or two, So it's hard to determine whats HOF worthy?
We might as well put in a lock on the HOF section and say, These are the chops that changed the world, no one else can ever get in.
Post edited November 09, 2010 at 11:34:06 PM by J_HUI
ffkZ5K.jpg
Come join us on Facebook and Tumblr
can i be on both sides ??

i agree on this part > somebody who doesnt have a real eye for hof or advanced stuff (yet)
is not familiair with the scene or what is up to ..... should not shout hof to quickly , without knowing what the standards of chopping is atm

but on the other hand > people with knowledge should give more opinions on promotions
for instance i saw a great choip of a chopper , with a great gallery also and nobody said they thought it was advanced (i did) , on his level i would have expected to see a few comments about a promotion

but i even have a nother opinion for me personally its not most important witch level i'm in
sure its nice to get promoted when people love your work but i dont pay attention to that or think about wanting promotion

its like when somebody likes your work thats cool if not also cool

but i still think to keep the community alive and shifting more people should give a opinion when they think its maybe promotion worthy

i also think nobody should ask for promotion thats weird imo
mijnlogo.jpg
rich wrote:
can i be on both sides ??

i agree on this part > somebody who doesnt have a real eye for hof or advanced stuff (yet)
is not familiair with the scene or what is up to ..... should not shout hof to quickly , without knowing what the standards of chopping is atm

but on the other hand > people with knowledge should give more opinions on promotions
for instance i saw a great choip of a chopper , with a great gallery also and nobody said they thought it was advanced (i did) , on his level i would have expected to see a few comments about a promotion

but i even have a nother opinion for me personally its not most important witch level i'm in
sure its nice to get promoted when people love your work but i dont pay attention to that or think about wanting promotion

its like when somebody likes your work thats cool if not also cool

but i still think to keep the community alive and shifting more people should give a opinion when they think its maybe promotion worthy

i also think nobody should ask for promotion thats weird imo

to be honest
i check trough really loads of chops
though i only comment small amount of them, that doesnt mean i dont check them out
if i spot something good/interesting enough for sure ill comment it/suggest promotion based on it
and ofcourse the different views of opinions are allowed, but i have seen that stuff posted on some chops that make me think is it an joke, fanboy'ish view of the work or just honest opinion...
yeah, even that, much much people ironically ask for promotion -not just"I vote HOF!!"- :doh:

agreed with Jack and J, Art is undefineable, and HOF is just for the art that never seen both in creating or the result that we never seen/far away from the word "insane"... CMIIW ..:D
Back to top

Please login to post