MOVED: VOTING: [BPC 2012] Round 2 - Division 2

VOTING: [BPC 2012] Round 2 - Division 2

IF YOU COMPETED IN THIS DIVISION, DO NOT VOTE IN THIS DIVISION.


For reference, here was the task:
Quote:
YOUR TASK

Honda S2000

The Honda S2000 is a truly iconic vehicle.

With the ASC competitors tackling a redesign of the S2000, we want you guys to tackle a slightly less demanding task of simply "chopping" the S2000.

Without further ado, here is your base image:

hondas20001.jpg



Mansory

hondas2000rosa800x600.jpg
WIP

_________________________________________________________________________

lycanthrophia

hondas2klkn.jpg
WIP

_________________________________________________________________________

Gile
s2k800x600.jpg

WIP

_________________________________________________________________________

RDJDesign
hondas2000bpcd2.jpg

WIP

_________________________________________________________________________

Cipprik
hondacipprik800.jpg

WIP

_________________________________________________________________________

zr1
hondabpcvgleges.jpg

WIP

_________________________________________________________________________

Adrianos
hondas2000k.jpg

WIP
WIP2
WIP3
WIP4
WIP5
WIP6

_________________________________________________________________________

T_T_f
55jyd1.jpg

WIP

_________________________________________________________________________



VOTING RULES

  • Do your best to vote unbiased towards others based on their nationality, or simply because you like/dislike them.
  • Do not vote in a division you have competed in.

  • Vote for the TOP 4 chops in the following format:

    4 points = M4D Creations (Given to the best entry)
    3 points = B0$$ Designs (Given to the second best entry)
    2 point = Puszka1232122312 (Given to the third best entry)
    2 point = Cool_designer (Given to the fourth best entry)

  • We ask you to write a farily extensive critique on the work of those that you are voting for. This should include an explanation of why you are placing the chop in that position.

The TOP 4 voted chops in this division progress to the Semi Final.
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
Aïe,
here is the killing zone...
Not easy to give a perfect advice, but i'll try to do my best... :-d :-d

4 points RDJ design
****
This realisation can be in the superior category... nice design, perfect realisation, great athmosphere, all is there for a awesome work :-d :-d
the best entry in the BPC at this moment :omg:

3 points T_T_F
***+
a very good parts integration... a perfect mix of sobriety and agressivity B)
just take care at the luminosity of the car into a nonsunny BG :/

2 points Gile
***
a high level realisation... athmo and détails are there...
but i don't understand, for exemple, the difference of reflection between cap and glasses... sad o.O

1 points Adrianos
***--
I hesitated a long time with Mansory... a enormous problem of BG perspective,
problems of shadows and wheels axes... but a beautifull brush work have decided me... take care @ this for the next round !!!
4 points = RDJDesign
+ Gorgeous! Awesome use of the brush!
- If I have to look for a minus, the background seems to be a little off.
Great work!

3 points = lycanthrophia
+ Wow, design is rough!
- Brushing is toony. If the brush would be better, this would have been almost perfect!

2 points = T_T_f
+ Great design!
- A little seems to have become a hurry to finish. Not quite the level of your other work.
But the great work!

1 point = Cipprik
+ Nice! The colors are great! Teddy is a great detail!
- You should have been ranked higher, but the design is "normal" and a little blurry work..
4 points RDJDesign, easy first place, nicest scene, awesome paint and refs AND styling is most to my liking, pro level chop or even advanced :P
3 points Cipprik
2 points lycanthrophia
1 point Adrianos, the background angle though?
I have to say, Im very very impressed with some of the chops in this division.

4pts: RDJDesign, What a great looking chop, I agree with Xanforce, I think it's one of the best entry in round 2 BPC. but IMO the front bumper can use a bit more lighting/ highlights as the front bumper look a bit matte compare to the side of the car.

3pts: Cipprik, big fan of the APR kit( I think) just needed a bit more work on the side of the car, the reflections on the bumper was great but didn't follow through to the side which lets it down.

2pts: lycanthrophia, I quite like the crazy widebody kit which is good to see people being creative. But it just lacked some reflections and highlight to make it look realistic.

1pts: Adrianos I love the colour and the wheel choice ALOT. but the rear wheel needs to be rotated clockwise a bit and the background angle is very off, it looks like the far rear wheel is lifted off the ground.

I also liked Mansory's entry but I recognized the chargespeed S200 image when I saw it.
ffkZ5K.jpg
Come join us on Facebook and Tumblr
4pts: T_T_f, looks kinda real, and it fits the background

3pts: RDJDesign, kinda toony, but nice lighting, looks shiny.

2pts: Adrianos, very good lighting/brushing, very off on the background/perspective.

1pts: Gile, just like a real, very blurry, photo.
Some men just want to watch the world doing burnouts... :P
bannerda.jpg bannerfb.jpg
Wish I could give points to 5 or 6 chops here that deserve it, there are a lot of top notch entries here!

4 Points = RDJDesign

Love the clean-ness of this chop. Probably the best executed chop here, and style wise it's simple but attractive. Love the gloomy atmosphere too!

3 Points = Cipprik

Nice brushing and a cool atmosphere overall. Side needs some reflections, and overall the brushing looks a little "one tone" throughout the car - needs one area of the car to be more well lit than others to look correct.

2 Points = Mansory

Although it's not the most realistic or the most jaw dropping of the other entries, you get top marks for execution with few mistakes. I like the body kit a lot, although the spoiler is a little large for my taste. Brushing needs more work - see my comment for Cipprik about it looking "one tone" as the same goes for yours.

1 Point = Adrianos

Another good entry. The brushwork is pretty good, although the reflections look a little odd in places, and I'd like to see some refs on the hood as well. Background looks a little off, and there are minor mistakes littered across the chop which held it back from getting points.

_________________________________________________________

Close but no cigar.....

lycanthropia - Radical design, but brushwork needs more to pull it off with style.

T_T_f - Kit is awesome, but way too many n00b errors to get points. Old background through the windows is just painful.
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
4p to T_T_f: Sweet modifications, looks badass!

3p to RDJDesign: Nice design on the front bumper. Only thing is, it could have used a more aggressive side skirt/rear arch to match the front. Great work on the paint too.

2p to Adrianos: I love the lighting and paint effect on this. Modifications are all done well although it does lose a bit of the S2000 characteristics because of the BMW-like side.

1p to Gile: I love the atmosphere in the image. Great background and reflections on the car.
Thread moved
Back to top

Please login to post