MOVED: VOTING: [BPC 2012] Semi Final

VOTING: [BPC 2012] Semi Final

IF YOU COMPETED IN THIS ROUND, DO NOT VOTE.


For reference, here was the task:
Quote:
YOUR TASK

Rivals Theme: Subaru WRX vs Mitsubishi Evo

Now that we've tested your more conventional chopping capabilities, we want to see the artistry and creativity hidden behind those more technical talents ...

In this Round we want you to compose a piece of art that represents the long and epic rivalry between two of the world's most distinctive sports vehicles: Subaru's WRX and Mitsubishi's Evo. You are free to choose whatever base images you like - be it the latest models from each manufacturer, or perhaps some that go back to the roots of the rivalry - creativity is all we ask!

With all this freedom comes a two crucial theme requirements:
- You may produce more than one final image as your entry
- However, one of your images must feature at least one WRX and one Evo in the same image

Have fun, try your best, and remember; be creative!



RDJDesign

subaruimprezawrxvsmitsh.jpg

WIPs & Donors

_________________________________________________________________________

NS Design

evo%20vs%20sti%20resized.jpg

WIPs & Donors

_________________________________________________________________________

iCreate

bpcsemifinalentryicreat.jpg

WIPs & Donors

_________________________________________________________________________

DaniG Design

finalxf.jpg

WIPs & Donors

_________________________________________________________________________

Cipprik

bpcsemifinalwip800.jpg

WIPs & Donors

_________________________________________________________________________


VOTING RULES

  • Do your best to vote unbiased towards others based on their nationality, or simply because you like/dislike them.
  • Do not vote in a division you have competed in.

  • Vote for the TOP 4 chops in the following format:

    4 points = M4D Creations (Given to the best entry)
    3 points = B0$$ Designs (Given to the second best entry)
    2 point = Puszka1232122312 (Given to the third best entry)
    2 point = Cool_designer (Given to the fourth best entry)

  • We ask you to write a farily extensive critique on the work of those that you are voting for. This should include an explanation of why you are placing the chop in that position.

The TOP 4 voted chops in progress to the Final.
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
Just making sure, is it a typo and are we supposed to give out 2 points to both the 3rd and the 4th?

4p to RDJ: Definitely the best mood in the image while also having a clear rivalry situation. Sweet work with the paint on the Evo!

3p to NS: Another one clearly having the rivalry going on. Nice work with the overall visual style in the image, the color coding in both the cars works fairly well. Tighter cropping of the image would have been in order. The tree reflections, especially on the WRX bother me a bit.

2p to iCreate: More like a body kit design but still fulfilling the rivalry criteria since they are clearly racing. Would have been better if they were closer together. Now it looks like a casual track day and the other car in front just happens to be an Evo. The most realistic out of all the entries though.

1p to Cipprik: It might be easy to see the pattern why I voted the top three and why the remaining entries are down in the back of the pack. In both Cipprik's and DaniG's works the cars are stationary, there's really no rivalry going on. "Who's parking harder?" No. I Gave the 4th place to Cipprik because of the styling. A bit unfinished but it's got nice body modifications and great looking wheels on both of the cars. Reflections on the paints look good too.

EDIT: Fixed it to say '1p'.
Post edited December 19, 2012 at 10:27:45 PM by ollite20
ollite20 wrote:
Just making sure, is it a typo and are we supposed to give out 2 points to both the 3rd and the 4th?

It's a typo. I have no idea how it appeared either! XD
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
4 points = RDJDesign
- A great job! Brushing is really successful, I love the color of the Subaru!
Nice work!

3 points = iCreate
- Realistic! Evo is a bit boring, it did not have to change the color. Impreza is nicely done. Finest coupe conversion what I have seen. Great job!

2 points = NS Design
- This reminds me of fast and furious, though there 's no much modified parts.

1 point = Cipprik
- This would be fine, but this is WIP. :/
4 points RDJ design
***+
a new time, the best of the BPC ;)
This one is not a 4stars like the Honda, but your brush is very, very, very exciting for my eyes...
just the contrast with the BG is unreal for me...
continue like this :mrteeth: :mrteeth:

3 points iCreate
***-
The Sub is a really good concept, execution and integration
the evoX is a little bit too classic... :/
great job

2 points Cipprik
**+
a really good job, just a big problems with the rear wheels of the Sub and the color integration...
take care, too, @ the BG perspective.
Welcome to the final ;)

1 point NS Design
**+
the athmosphere is really great, one of the best concept on this division...
but the effects are too many "rough" for a better place...
:-d
4 Points = RDJDesign

Great work here! I'm loving the lighting, atmosphere and effects. Although the execution could still be better, it's hard to criticise you considering you're only an Intermediate artist!

3 Points = Cipprik

It's clear you put a lot of effort in this, and the result is really good. Unlike a couple of the other entries, you chose matching generation cars which was the best approach in my opinion.

2 Points = iCreate

Very nice idea taking the cars to the track (their home territory). There seems to be a lot of technical faults with the chop though. The Evo in the background is too small, lighting between the cars and background doesn't match, and really it just lacks any real visual interest in my mind.

1 Point = DaniG Design

Hard to choose between your entry and NS Design's in my opinion. As I can't choose between, I'm going for your entry based on the fact that your previous round entries have showed a higher level of skill.
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
4 points RDJ design
Perspective might be an issue but nice job on making it a night chop. Loads of nice details.

3 points iCreate
Scores high on realism.

2 points Cipprik
Nice mods and good effort, it lacks some finishing details though, reflection wise.

1 point NS Design
For the "spectacular" look mostly, don't get the angle of the road and certain reflections but it's a cool image.
4 points,- NS Design. No big flaws that I can tell, and awesome style, even if it may look a bit more like a video game than reality.

3 points,- RDJDesign, very nice lighting effect, but some toony parts, and a slightly more off rear wheel than on NS's chop. Very close between you two I think.

2 points,- Icreate, very realistic, and I like the 2 door Impreza. Not the most exiting or artistic one though, a bit boring, like my own ASC entry...

1 point,-DaniG Design, not too bad, but looks unfinished, and reflections still look like the same car twice.

Cipprik did a good job on the brushing, but still looks toony/unfinished.
Some men just want to watch the world doing burnouts... :P
bannerda.jpg bannerfb.jpg
4 points = RDJDesign - for me the most successful entry of this round, showing the two rivals really head to head. Not only that, but it has the best atmosphere and shows the highest level of technical skill - overall a very good chop! :D

3 points = Cipprik - I'm surprised others haven't voted this high, as for me it's by far the most creative of the remaining entries. The designs look really cool, and you've clearly put a lot of effort into this! It's a shame that it's a wip, but even so it shows more thought and attention to detail than some of the other chops, so well done :D

2 points = iCreate - some nice ideas here, creating more aggressive cars in their natural environment xD The background seems to fit well, but overall it does look rather cool. However the lighting on the cars doesn't seem to match up, and while you may be able to get away with that on the evo (low down sun in the sky on the bg too), it just doesn't make sense on the impreza. But a good effort none the less :)

1 point = DaniG Design - although both cars seem very nearly stock, of the remaining entries this feels most complete and believable, and has fewest mistakes. I think the main problem is the rims on the evo - I don't think their style quite suits the car, but mainly they seem to bright and have no reflection on the ground - this is only a minor problem though.

Good luck to all :-d
125q72h.jpg
>>Latest Chop<<
| >>Like my Facebook Page<< | >>Basic Brushing Tutorial<<
4 points
RDJDesign
The atmosphere and brushing is the best among all the entries. Well done.

3 points
Cipprik
Although it is still quite in a wip form, but I can some potential in it. If you could complete it, it would be good.

2 points
iCreate
The Subaru looks good, mods are well done and fits to the bg nicely too. But the Evo just bothers me a lot, the lighting don't really fit with the bg. And the position of it is also wrong, making it looks weird. More blurring on it might help too since the car is going to be far from the Subaru depends on the size of it right now.

1 points
DaniG Design
Not many mods on both of the car, but they look good to me. Love the atmosphere of the chop and also the reflection on the floor. Evo's wheels don't look quite right though.
:awesome:
dA
Back to top

Please login to post