MOVED: VOTING: ASC Round 1 - Division 1

VOTING: [ASC 2012] Round 1 - Division 1

ascinterlaced.png

IF YOU COMPETED IN THIS DIVISION, DO NOT VOTE IN THIS DIVISION.


For reference, here was the task:
Quote:
YOUR TASK

2013 Hyundai Genesis Coupe

Here we have the latest offering of the Genesis Coupe from Korean manufacturer, Hyundai. A car that has attracted much attention for it's curvaceous, yet aggressive lines, we want you to make it look even better!

We have no real restrictions for how we want you to modify the base this round, however we do want you to keep the car distinctly a Hyundai Genesis - don't go creating a spaceship out of it!

Judges will be looking for entries that feature modifications that seem realistic to carry out, and work that displays a high technical ability. There are two base images to work your magic on - we highly suggest you tackle both!

frontmedium.jpg



rearmedium.jpg



hugosilva
frontlowd.jpg

rearlow.jpg
_________________________________________________________________________

Glacius

preview.jpg
_________________________________________________________________________

Zykotec

crapsmall.jpg
crapsmallrear.jpg
_________________________________________________________________________

Ice Devil

valmishyundai.jpg
_________________________________________________________________________

VOTING RULES
  • Do your best to vote unbiased towards others based on their nationality, or simply because you like/dislike them.
  • Do not vote in a division you have competed in.

  • Vote for the TOP 3 chops in the following format:

    3 points = M4D Creations (Given to the best entry)
    2 points = B0$$ Designs (Given to the second best entry)
    1 point = Puszka1232122312 (Given to the third best entry)

  • We ask you to write a farily extensive critique on the work of those that you are voting for. This should include an explanation of why you are placing the chop in that position.
[/quote]
The TOP 4 voted chops in this division progress to Round 2.
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
3 Points = hugosilva

You've produced two stunning pieces of art here. Stand-out of the division, although probably not my favourite of this round. A few bits seem a bit fake and I'm not a fan of the design/style.

2 Points = Glacius

Simple, effective and well executed. What more does it need? Well perhaps it's a little too simple, but I do love the rear version. Front bumper looks odd - the far side seems to lift up off the ground too much. A bit more finishing and perhaps something a little more audacious in terms styling and atmosphere would have fetched 3 points from me.

1 Point = Zykotec

Love the idea/theme. The front view is stunning - cool atmosphere and well executed. Rear needs something to set it off. Seems very bland in comparison, but good job overall!
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
3p to hugosilva
Great kit and livery design! Background choices really set it off. Sweet water effects too! I'm not impressed by the exhaust flames though but that's the only and minor crit I can think of.

2p to Zykotec
A bit sloppy there with the paint but the mood in the images and the balls-to-the-wall attitude compensate well.

1p to Glacius
Amazing execution and some solid styling there but to me it's basically stock with new wheels and a different paint color. Don't get me wrong, I would drive a Genesis that looked this good but still, photoshop-wise it's quite basic.

Ice Devil
Well fitted kit! Only the rear wing position bothers me a bit here. I feel it should be further in the back. And you should have removed the stock wing. With a little more interesting background choice and the lighting to match this one would have been at the 2p spot for me. Now it's just a bit behind on attitude vs Zyko's entry and execution vs Glac's.
3 points = Hugo Silva - very creative and as always to a very high standard. What tops it off is the atmosphere, however it does feel very toony. But I guess 100% realism wasn't the aim here. The real issue for me are those rims, they simply don't seem to suit the chop in my opinion. But yeh, one of the better entries of this round - well done :D

2 points = Zykotec - damn. Actually loved this! Those colours and that styling look totally sweet! :D The front looks brutal, and the overall feeling to the chop (what really matters) is simply great :) Admire your bravery with such a crazy chop too, and this time, it's paid off :D Nice one

1 point = Ice Devil - A lot of stock parts, but I love the way this looks! It actually looks like a proper GT racer! The bg and kit fit really well, and as an overall piece it's a good chop. Just the left arch lets it down for me.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

For me, glacius's chop wasn't to the standard of the others, and seemed to show the least creativity. Even by my standards it seemed extremely simplistic. What worked for it however was the atmosphere, consistent on front and rear views, however, then I looked at the full size image. To me it looks really rushed, like mostly stock paint (with a few levels played with in places) and some really very toony rough reflections brushed over the top of the base reflections. You've then added a few more which really seem to make no sense at all in some places. Final issue is with the rims, 3 out of the four visible ones seem to be off. So for me there seem to be a lot of flaws, which is why, you unfortunately take my fourth place spot.
125q72h.jpg
>>Latest Chop<<
| >>Like my Facebook Page<< | >>Basic Brushing Tutorial<<
3 points Hugo Silva
****+
a new great creation of Hugo... :-d
the front view (my favorite) is really impressive.
the bodykit is a little bit too complicated for me but the realisation of the two views is perfect... just take care @ your symetry and your logo applications.
the Autobacs logo and the lateral Bridgestone are off !

2 points Glacius
****
the rear view is just perfect !
sobriety, execution, realism, details,... just maybe a little too simple.
somes tyres and reflexions problems are also there...
But i love the pink touch and the general effect ! :-d

1 point Zykotec
***
Let's go for crazy... =O =O
a great athmosphere, but take care at hte BG perspective and the realism of your brush...
but your idea was incredible !

Ice Devil
**+
a good chop but too much mistakes to have point.
rear wheels, black too flat, integration of the stickers are the most important :/
it's sad because the idea and the bodykit was really great :-d
Post edited September 12, 2012 at 07:32:51 PM by -xanforce-
3 Points - HugoSilva
Amazing work, just front view background is confusing and flames could be better.

2 Points - Glacius
Great atmosphere, very clean. Nice and simple colour scheme and all the hues are the same. Could maybe have a bit more tire on the wheels.

1 Point - Zykotec
Really like the front view but not so much the rear one. Very creative like usual.
Background has a different perspective than the car in the rear view.
Also the backgrounds lack something, not sure what though?
Lets do it fast ;)

3p - Hugo
2p - Glac
1p - IceD
3 points - hugosilva: Not a fan of the livery design, but this is the best chop in this division. The black paint looks awesome, and the WIPs show the so much work. Ideas pretty original, furthermore while considering this was the first submission. Little flaws here and there, but overal pretty great job!

2 points - Glacius:
Quite simple, maybe too simple, would have liked more designing here and there, but the quality looks pretty perfect for me. It's the execution why I gave the second place to this entry.

1 point - Zykotec: Looks like the most creative entry, but to be honnest I dont like the color combo. The bodykit is pretty awesome thought, one of the best design of all divisons. Some minor flaws, and a bit toony, but nice job!
3pts - hugosilva
2pts - Glacius
1pt - Zykotec
Back to top

Please login to post