MOVED: VOTING: ASC Round 1 - Division 3

VOTING: [ASC 2012] Round 1 - Division 3

ascinterlaced.png

IF YOU COMPETED IN THIS DIVISION, DO NOT VOTE IN THIS DIVISION.


For reference, here was the task:
Quote:
YOUR TASK

2013 Hyundai Genesis Coupe

Here we have the latest offering of the Genesis Coupe from Korean manufacturer, Hyundai. A car that has attracted much attention for it's curvaceous, yet aggressive lines, we want you to make it look even better!

We have no real restrictions for how we want you to modify the base this round, however we do want you to keep the car distinctly a Hyundai Genesis - don't go creating a spaceship out of it!

Judges will be looking for entries that feature modifications that seem realistic to carry out, and work that displays a high technical ability. There are two base images to work your magic on - we highly suggest you tackle both!

frontmedium.jpg



rearmedium.jpg


GTstudio

ASCcomp_gtstudio.jpg
Reference
Reference
_________________________________________________________________________

Matt_K
frontdonen.jpg
WIPs

reardone.jpg
WIPs
_________________________________________________________________________

SatwikaDe

hyundaifprojects.jpg
WIPs

hyundaibproject1.jpg
WIPs
_________________________________________________________________________


VOTING RULES
  • Do your best to vote unbiased towards others based on their nationality, or simply because you like/dislike them.
  • Do not vote in a division you have competed in.

  • Vote for the TOP 3 chops in the following format:

    3 points = M4D Creations (Given to the best entry)
    2 points = B0$$ Designs (Given to the second best entry)
    1 point = Puszka1232122312 (Given to the third best entry)

  • We ask you to write a farily extensive critique on the work of those that you are voting for. This should include an explanation of why you are placing the chop in that position.
The TOP 4 voted chops in this division progress to Round 2.
Post edited September 09, 2012 at 10:17:20 PM by Klaus
puszka321 wrote:
please video xD
MK211 wrote:
I really like the nos coming out of the rims
3 points - GTstudio (i wish i had a rear view of tha, but even with a front view only, this takes my first place, as the whole chop is clean and realistic, its perfect to my eyes and we dont have no one finishing rear views on this division, so...)

2 points - Matt K (very good colour wich seems brushed to me, legit, good chop, i have some doubts on the rear view tough, to much copy past from another genesis, if he had finished this wip and entered it i would give him the secon place, im giving it for the front view only)

1 point - Satwikade (its not a bad chop, but i dont know both views seem unfinished, the rearprobably is unfinished anyway, its not to bad anyway)
Post edited September 09, 2012 at 10:46:45 PM by hugosilva
3 points - GTstudio
Most realistic background changem, loads of work into this getting it to fit in the scene looks brilliant, shame it is a bit toony and the rearview is missing =( love the wheels but rear one looks a tad to big but its great overall


2 points - Matt K
Same as above great scenery change and realism is ok, just again shame noe rearview, love the wheels and color on the car .

1 point - Satwikade
Front view looks simple but great, there is outdoor nightscene reflections on front bumper looks a bit wierd., and the white line above the image dont suit it ruins it imo you do not need to show where the lightsource is coming from just kills the image, but overall nice work shame rear view is not done .
3pts - GTstudio
- Wonderful, so smooth brushing, but seems to still a bit WIP (front skirt, tires, side skirt ..), but otherwise is a great job, so the first place.

2pts - Matt K
- Great work!
- Rear wheel and the hood is a bit low quality.
- Why did you send a blurred rear image? Second last WIP would be much sharper.

1pt - Satwikade
- Also this is a good chop!
- The atmosphere is gorgeous.
- Rear image is a bit too dark. A little brighter, it would be much better.

Great work guys! :-d
3 points - GTstudio: Althought you did not complete the whole task, this is the best chop of this division. Brushing is pretty realistic, and clean. Goes well on this background.

2 points - Matt_K: Had hard time choosing from this and Satwikade's one, but choose this one because I like this one more. It's a pitty you submitted a blured rear, I liked the WIPs of it.. Anyway, front looks good.

1 point - Satwikade: Got the third place because the rear view. I just dont know, maybe my screen is too dark, but this seems like a big black hole with some white lines on it. The front looks pretty good, I like the way how you turned on the headlights.
3 points - Satwikade, finished both views, I think? I loove the dark rear viw, but front view could be better.
2points - GTstudio, best brush on finished angle, as clean as we are used to, needs more mods, but the few subtle ones s still enough to recognize it ;)
1 point - Matt K, front view is a bit toony, hod is not good, rear view looks cool, but hard to even recognize he car model...
Some men just want to watch the world doing burnouts... :P
bannerda.jpg bannerfb.jpg
3p to GTstudio
It was a difficult choice between this and Matt_K for first place but due to superior technical execution I chose this. Also the wheels look proportionate to the car's body.

2p to Matt_K
Sweet lighting and unique paint colour are definitely the best parts here. Great work on the front bumper as well, making it a bit more unique instead of sticking completely with the stock shapes. It looks like the car has been lowered a bit too much. Because of that the front wheel is made too small compared to the body. Ruins the proportions a little bit. Rear view only makes this confusing. First of all the car is different colour, secondly it's all blurry and the image is too dark to figure out if there's really something done to the rear bumper. It would have been better to just leave it out and just post the finished front view.

1p to Satwikade
Another slightly confusing case of different paints in the views. Am I looking at the same car or is the other one supposed to be an alternate design? Out of these, the car in the rear view looks more interesting. Just wishing it was a bit brighter to figure out if there are any details. Front view, although having more details hurts the overall a bit in my opinion. Front bumper is 100% taken off another car model (using the stock Genesis bumper would have been the better bet for overall design). It's also off-perspective. Tires are stuck in the wheel arches.
As I go through each division, the number of WIPs and references posted keeps going down -.-

3 points = SatwikeDe - Finished both front and rear, and both clearly the same car! Well done! :D Also been done to a very high standard, and even if a lot was C+P, I know the donor and the effort that has gone into these. The resulting atmosphere is really cool, so very well done :)

2 points = Matt_K - So close to putting you first, but the realism and overly blurred ridiculous rearview of a different car let it down XD So i'll leave the rear there. Front view looks nicely brushed, although is a little toony, but the overall feel and styling is spot on - loving that kit with the stance :D

1 point = GTStudio - This looked quite promising (if a little boring) on the small view, but viewing the full size revealed a whole host of noob mistakes, poor selections and very toony, unfinished brushing. It also lacks a rearview of any description, and of the few styling mods you have added, I can't say I like any of them from a personal perspective. But hey, you can't please everyone :D
125q72h.jpg
>>Latest Chop<<
| >>Like my Facebook Page<< | >>Basic Brushing Tutorial<<
a really complexe division...
between only one view or two view with somes mistakes... what must i doing?

3 points GT studio
****
the best standards in this division :-d
sobriety, cleanliness of realization, color and reflection, integration...
all is good ! just maybe "too" classics...
WellDone :-d

2 points MattK
***
an excellent work with a beautifull color... arear wheels too big for me and sommes reflections a bit off...
but an excellent level :-d

1 point SatwikaDe
***-
you merits certainly better since you had made the 2 views but you have also, a lot of little mistakes in your chop...
take care at your shadow, your wheels perspectives and somes reflexions.
you have the quality to pass the next round :-d
3 points: GT studio

i gotta say i love the simple style of it, and the brushing!
there is a few flaws, like jaggies and lack of noise, other than that, it´s lovely!

2 points: Matt_K

quite nice and clean style, and the brushing looks nice!
though there are quite a few flaws, like the car looks stretched, the toe-in/out on the rear wheel is too much toe out, and the hood doesn´t suit the rest of the car, style-wise or lighting-wise.

and the rear view is too much C/P for my taste, also it woul look alot better without the blur

1 point: SatwikaDe

at first i was going to place you 2nd, but then i realised it was auite alot of C/P on the front view, and the front view fb, and hood is not really similar to the original in any way, nor proportioned to the original lines, aand the shutlines look really fake compared to the C/P:ed body.

and the rear just look like it´s done in a rush.
Welcome to Wigs-Lace. Offering wigs, hair extensions, falls :awesome:

hotnigbum.jpg

ToMiii @Facebook
Back to top

Please login to post